Rotten Tomatoes Reviews of ‘The Old Guard 2’ Reveal Critics’ Discontent

Charlize Theron’s highly anticipated sequel, ‘The Old Guard 2,’ has been met with disappointing reviews from Rotten Tomatoes critics, scoring a low 25% ‘rotten’ rating based on 48 reviews. The film, which debuted on Netflix on July 3, 2025, continues the story of immortal warriors, led by Andy (Theron), as they fight to protect the world. However, critics have expressed dissatisfaction with various elements of the movie, including its rushed plot, poor fight choreography, and weak character development. While some praise Theron’s performance, others feel that the sequel does not live up to its predecessor, with criticisms of a confusing narrative and lackluster pacing. Notably, top critics such as Benjamin Lee from The Guardian and Keith Maher from The Times have given the film a ‘rotten’ rating, pointing out its technical flaws and storytelling issues. On the other hand, a few critics have offered more tempered reviews, with William Bibbiani from The Wrap acknowledging the film’s action but highlighting its forgettable nature. The film, directed by Victoria Mahoney, also stars Uma Thurman and is available to stream on Netflix.